LTC John Hunter (United States Army (Retired)), former Director of Football Operations, Associate Athletics Director Recruiting/Admissions, Army West Point Athletics Department, United States Military Academy at West Point. The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Walk the Talk Foundation and its members. (Published February 1st, 2025)
Check out our Podcast, The Star Chamber, on: Apple l Spotify l YouTube
A Marred Chapter in an Honorable Career
What ought to have been the crowning achievement of a 25-year career in the United States Army instead became a sobering reminder of the challenges that remain in safeguarding the integrity of our institutions. My tenure at the United States Military Academy at West Point, from April 2021 until my retirement in May 2024, offered opportunities for professional growth yet was marked by systemic failures, a toxic culture, and leadership that strayed from the values it was sworn to uphold.
I entered this chapter of service with high expectations, equipped with the skills and resolve honed during a career in the 1st Special Forces Command and Joint Special Operations Command. The assignment to the Army West Point Athletics Department (AWPAD) was an opportunity to combine my military experience with my academic background in Sport Administration, contributing to the development of collegiate athletics at the highest level. Yet, alongside the privilege of service came the revelation of leadership shortcomings and operational dysfunction that could not be ignored.
A Transition with Purpose
Arriving at West Point in April 2021, I undertook a range of responsibilities spanning operations, logistics, and human resources. These roles required the establishment of systems where none existed, a challenge that was met with the diligence expected of any officer. By August 2021, I transitioned to a focused role in operations and, subsequently, took on the demanding position of Director of Football Operations. This role encompassed admissions liaison duties, player development, and on-campus recruiting, placing operational demands on par with those of a deployment.
Despite unwavering dedication, opportunities to take leave were denied, resulting in an accumulation of over 30 days of unused leave by the end of 2022. The intensity of the workload was compounded by a work environment that failed to reflect the values of professionalism and mutual respect expected within the Army.
The Challenge of Leadership and Ethics
From the outset, it became apparent that the culture within AWPAD was riddled with unprofessionalism, nepotism, and a disregard for Army regulations. The leadership of key figures, including Deputy Athletic Director COL Gretchen Nunez, Former Senior Associate Athletic Director LTC (RET) John Nawoichyk, and Associate Athletics Director – Broadcasting and Licensing Richard DeMarco, reflected priorities misaligned with the principles of accountability and fairness.
By January 2022, my workload increased without commensurate support, and by August of the same year, I was abruptly reassigned to the U.S. Military Academy staff. This transition lacked justification and resulted in my placement in a role that not only misused my qualifications but also violated ethical standards by involving cash-handling duties in direct contravention of regulations. These assignments exacerbated an existing shoulder injury, further straining my ability to perform.
A Necessary Step: Filing the Inspector General Complaint
In September 2022, I sought the counsel of the West Point Inspector General regarding the systemic issues I encountered. While my concerns were acknowledged as valid, I was cautioned against expecting meaningful change and advised to simply endure. This unsatisfactory response epitomized the systemic inertia that undermines the Army’s mechanisms for accountability.
Only after securing my retirement did I formally file a complaint in April 2023. This complaint outlined several critical failures:
- Misuse of Personnel: Assignments violating regulations and disregarding qualifications.
- Disregard for Medical Profiles: Neglect of documented medical conditions, resulting in further physical harm.
- Compromised Evaluations: Pressure to falsify officer evaluations, eroding the integrity of the process.
- Toxic Leadership: Instances of retaliation, rumor-mongering, and marginalization.
Despite substantiating my claims with evidence, the complaint was ultimately dismissed. This outcome, though expected, underscored the broader challenges of enforcing accountability within the institution.
Reflections on Reform and Responsibility
The systemic issues I encountered at West Point reflect a larger malaise within leadership culture—one that permits ethical lapses, tolerates unprofessionalism, and diminishes the morale of those it is meant to lead. The failure of the Inspector General system to act decisively is emblematic of the broader reluctance to confront these issues head-on.
This culture of inaction sends a disheartening message: that raising legitimate concerns may invite retaliation rather than resolve. Such conditions are not only corrosive to trust but also inimical to the values of duty, honor, and respect that the Army holds dear.
A Call to Renewed Purpose
As I transition to civilian life, my resolve to advocate for ethical leadership and systemic reform remains undiminished. The Army must rise to the challenge of addressing the structural and cultural flaws that undermine its mission. Key measures include:
- Reforming Accountability Systems: Ensuring the Inspector General process functions transparently and effectively.
- Strengthening Leadership Training: Prioritizing ethical decision-making and adherence to regulations.
- Protecting Whistleblowers: Safeguarding individuals who raise concerns from retaliation.
- Enforcing Standards: Holding leaders accountable for breaches of professionalism and integrity.
True reform is not a matter of convenience but a necessity to preserve the honor and efficacy of the Army. Leadership must embody the values it expects of its soldiers, ensuring that the sacrifices of service are met with dignity and respect.
While my time at West Point did not conclude as envisioned, it has reaffirmed my commitment to fostering environments where integrity and accountability prevail. The Army’s potential to serve as a beacon of professionalism remains undiminished, but this requires confronting its shortcomings with courage and conviction. Only through genuine reform can the Army fully honor its duty to those who serve under its banner.
Send this newsletter to your elected officials if you believe they need to correct the issues discussed.
- Find your Representative here: https://www.house.gov/representatives/find-your-representative
- Find your Senator here: https://www.senate.gov/senators/senators-contact.htm
Feel free to reach out privately at francescagraham@walkthetalkfoundation.org.
PETITIONS:
- SIGN THIS PETITION demanding that our leaders in Congress change the DoD’s unjust administrative investigatory system.
- SIGN THIS PETITION demanding real anti-harassment reform in the Military and Coast Guard now.
- SIGN THIS PETITION urging the Supreme Court of the United States to hear the case of Staff Sergeant Ryan Carter who was paralyzed from the chest down following a routine surgery at Walter Reed.
If you would like to help us fight these issues, please consider donating to the Walk the Talk Foundation via either Venmo or PayPal. We greatly appreciate your support.
All our articles are posted on LinkedIn here and Online here. Be sure to subscribe to the newsletter on LinkedIn and follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and X (Twitter).
Graphics: USMA Logo [United States Military Academy | 03] – PNG Logo Vector Brand Downloads (SVG, EPS), Rich DeMarco – Associate Athletics Director – Broadcasting and Licensing – Staff Directory – Army West Point, Col. Gretchen Nunez – Interim Head Women’s Soccer Coach – Staff Directory – Army West Point, https://www.linkedin.com/in/johnnawoichyk.